Photo by Kelly Sue, shared via
Flickr.
Have you ever met a parent who allows free access to sweets and desserts for their children? It isn't likely - most parents feel it is important to restrict their child's sugar intake in one way or another, with the goal of teaching smart, long-term feeding behaviors about food.
But what if the opposite was true? What if giving your children unlimited access to sweets and desserts would set them up for lasting healthy relationships with these foods? As a pediatric dietitian, I am not necessarily condoning this approach, but just asking you to consider it. And I'll be testing this theory with my own 2.5-year-old daughter in my own home - but more on that in a minute.
Several years ago, I attended an unforgettable lecture given by James, a childhood feeding expert. Although I can't remember the exact title of the lecture or the speaker’s last name, I do recall one specific story that he shared with the audience. James told us about his son, age 10 at the time, and his peculiar eating habits at home. He went onto to explain that when his son was just a toddler, James decided to create a "sweets drawer" at home, which was always easily accessible for kids. He filled this drawer with all types of typically restricted desserts - chocolate bars, candy, cookies, sodas, etc. And for the first week after the snack drawer was created, James' son went crazy and stuffed himself full with these sweet treats. But after only one week, he started to notice that his son was paying much less attention to the sweets.
Ten years after creating this drawer, James couldn't be happier about his decision to create the sweets drawer so many years ago. He asked the audience to guess who ate 99% of those sweets in the drawer in the years that followed? The answer: All of his son’s friends! Most of the time, other children couldn't believe that such a thing even existed and they went crazy to come over to his house! James went onto to elaborate on the concept that restricting foods, for kids and adults alike, often increases the desire for it.
I can't make up my mind how I feel about this approach for my child, but it is an interesting concept. What do you think?
Growing up in my family, we were not allowed to drink soda pop. Every once in a blue moon, my mom allowed us to have a caffeine-free root beer. But on my first day of high school, I found the vending machine in the hallway and learned that you could take soda to class with you - I thought I had died and gone to heaven! So guess what I did? I drank a Dr. Pepper every single early morning of my freshman year in high school! And this begs the question - what if my mom had given me soda pop just once a week as a child? Would I still have overconsumed these sugary drinks as a teenager? It is a really tough one to answer!
In 1999, the
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition published a study on this sweets and sugar restrictions among the families of preschool-aged children. According to this study, if you restrict children's access to "forbidden" foods, it may lead to overindulgence later.
When my daughter turned one year old, I started to think a lot more about this concept. Should I create a drawer like this?
Intuitively, it simply doesn’t feel right to stash a bunch of junk food into a kitchen cabinet and give her free access to it. But I also want her to grow up with a healthy approach towards all foods, particularly the nutritional nightmare foods. But, believe it or not…I am going to try it for my now 2.5-year-old daughter. It will just be a trial, and I can’t promise that I will keep the drawer forever, but I will do it as a test run for all of you. (And I am still going to be diligent about preparing balanced, nutritious meals for breakfast, lunch and dinner). For two weeks, I will also give her unlimited access to desserts when we are outside of the home. And of course, I will let you know how it goes!
When you were a kid, how was dessert time handled in your family? How do you think that impacted your relationship with food today? And how do you handle desserts in your home now?